Candidate relationship management

ATS vs. CRM: Which Recruiting Tech Should You Actually Use?

Applicant tracking systems, Candidate relationship management

Hey everyone, Kira here! If you work in recruiting (or, like me, have handled IT for recruiting teams), you’ve probably heard the acronyms ATS and CRM thrown around a lot. They both sound important, but let’s be honest—figuring out which one you need (or whether you need both) can be a total head-scratcher. So, let’s break it down in plain English, with examples and some hard-earned IT perspective.

ATS vs CRM

What’s an ATS, Anyway?

Think of your Applicant Tracking System (ATS) as the super-organized digital file cabinet for your hiring process. Every application, every resume, every interview note—your ATS keeps it all neat and trackable. Need to move a candidate from “screening” to “offer”? The ATS has your back. It’s a must-have for handling high volumes of applicants and keeping the process from spiraling out of control.

And What About CRM?

A Candidate Relationship Management (CRM) system is more like your long-term relationship builder. While your ATS is focused on filling open reqs right now, your CRM is helping you nurture connections with passive talent—people who aren’t applying yet, but could be a great fit down the line. Newsletters, talent pools, event invites, “just checking in” emails? That’s all CRM territory.

Key Differences (And Why They Matter)

  • Purpose: ATS is for processing and managing job applicants; CRM is for building and maintaining candidate relationships.
  • When It Kicks In: ATS starts working the moment someone applies. CRM works before that, helping you engage talent even if you don’t have a job open.
  • What It Stores: ATS = applications, interview stages, offer letters. CRM = notes on interests, sourcing history, engagement activities, and more.

How ATS and CRM Work Together (The Synergy Part)

Here’s the magic: The best recruiting teams don’t pick just one. They use both, and often blend them so seamlessly you hardly notice where one stops and the other starts.

Picture this: You’ve been building a relationship with a developer for months—sending them event invites and the occasional “hope you’re well!” email via your CRM. Suddenly, the perfect job opens up. You move them into your ATS and fast-track their application, using all that background context to make the process feel personal and smooth. That’s recruiting done right.

Real Tools for Real Recruiting Teams

📋 Top 3 Standalone ATS Platforms

  1. Greenhouse
    An enterprise-level favorite for structured workflows, integrations, and analytics. Used by big names for a reason.
  2. BambooHR
    Perfect for small to mid-sized businesses. Simple interface, solid ATS features, and great onboarding tools.
  3. Recruitee
    Offers customizable pipelines, AI-driven candidate matching, and easy job board integrations—great for fast-moving teams.

🤝 Top 3 CRM Solutions for Recruiting

  1. Manatal
    Known for its AI-powered talent recommendations and social media enrichment. Helps you build and nurture strong talent pools.
  2. Recruiterflow
    Agency-friendly CRM with intuitive UX, talent pipeline automation, and email/SMS outreach built in
  3. Zoho Recruit
    Combines CRM features with candidate sourcing and marketing automation. Good for agencies and SMBs.

🌐 Top 3 Hybrid Platforms (ATS + CRM Combined)

  1. Recruit CRM
    Seamlessly blends ATS and CRM functions, making it ideal for agencies that want everything in one place.
  2. Bullhorn
    A staffing industry classic, Bullhorn gives you full ATS and CRM power—plus integrations for VMS and reporting.
  3. LeverTRM
    Their “Talent Relationship Management” platform brings together candidate nurturing and structured recruiting under one (very slick) roof.

So, Which Should You Use?

  • ATS-only tools are perfect if you’re drowning in applicants and need to keep hiring organized and compliant.
  • CRM-only systems are best if you want to build a future talent pipeline and don’t have tons of current openings.
  • Hybrid platforms (with both ATS and CRM) give you the best of both worlds—especially for agencies, growing companies, or any team that wants to save time and avoid data headaches.

IT Wisdom: Integration Makes All the Difference

From my time supporting recruiters, trust me—integrating these tools (or picking a hybrid) is where the magic really happens. Recruiters spend less time toggling between tabs, and candidates feel like they’re getting a more personal (and less clunky) experience.

Bottom Line:
Don’t think of ATS vs. CRM as an either/or question. The future of recruiting is using both—either as standalone tools that play nice together, or as an all-in-one platform. That way, you stay organized and keep relationships warm, all while making sure no great candidate slips through the cracks.

FAQ: ATS vs. CRM in Recruiting—What Should You Really Use?

What’s the main difference between an ATS and a CRM in recruiting?

An ATS (Applicant Tracking System) is your go-to for managing the entire hiring process—think of it as the ultimate organizer for job applications, interviews, and hiring steps. A CRM (Candidate Relationship Management), on the other hand, is about building and maintaining relationships with talent before they ever apply. If you want to keep tabs on passive candidates, send newsletters, or stay in touch for future openings, that’s where a CRM shines.

Do I really need both an ATS and a CRM, or can I get by with just one?

It depends on your hiring goals! If you’re overwhelmed with active applicants and need structure, an ATS is a must. If your focus is on nurturing talent for future roles, a CRM is your best friend. But honestly, most modern recruiting teams get the best results by using both—either as separate tools that “talk” to each other or as an all-in-one hybrid platform.

What are the benefits of using a hybrid ATS+CRM platform?

A hybrid platform combines the best of both worlds. You can track active applicants while also building a long-term talent pool—without switching between systems. From an IT and user experience perspective, this means less hassle, smoother workflows, and a better candidate journey (trust me, your recruiters and candidates will both thank you).

What the Heck Is a Candidate Relationship Management System— Why Should Recruiters Care?

Candidate relationship management

Let’s be real: keeping track of great candidates shouldn’t feel like searching for your car keys in the dark. But for plenty of recruiters, that’s the deal. One week you connect with a dream candidate on LinkedIn, and the next week—poof—they’re lost in an inbox somewhere. I’ve seen the chaos firsthand, both from the recruiter’s side and from my seat in recruiting IT support.

That’s why Candidate Relationship Management systems—CRMs for short—are a game-changer. Instead of waiting for a job to open and then scrambling, you build real relationships with talent long before you have an open req. It’s how smart recruiters go from playing catch-up to actually being ahead of the curve.

Candidate Relationship Management Systems
Growing strong candidate relationships — one email at a time!

That’s why Candidate Relationship Management systems—CRMs for short—are a game-changer. Instead of waiting for a job to open and then scrambling, you build real relationships with talent long before you have an open req. It’s how smart recruiters go from playing catch-up to actually being ahead of the curve.

So, What Does a Candidate Relationship Management Actually Do?

Imagine a CRM as your personal candidate vault, follow-up machine, and brand ambassador all rolled into one. Here’s how it makes your day-to-day recruiting life way easier:

  • Never lose a great candidate again. CRMs keep everyone organized—by skill, interest, or whatever matters to you. Want every “data analyst” you’ve talked to in the last year? That’s one search, not ten wild email digs.
  • Build relationships before you need them. No more starting from scratch for every role. With a CRM, you can keep in touch, nurture, and stay on your top candidates’ radar—even if you don’t have a job for them yet.
  • Look like a pro brand (even on a small team). Automated, branded outreach and career pages let you punch above your weight, so your candidate experience rivals the big firms.
  • Hire faster—without the panic. When a job opens, you’ve already got a pipeline of warm, qualified people who know and trust you.

The Features That Actually Matter (Not Just Buzzwords)

Modern CRMs are so much more than glorified spreadsheets. Here’s what you should look for (and what recruiters tell me they use every day):

  • Talent Pools & Resume Parsing: No more lost files. Everything’s in one, searchable place.
  • Advanced Search (Boolean, AI, etc.): Find exactly who you need, fast.
  • Email & SMS Automation: Bulk personalized outreach, without sounding like a robot.
  • Candidate Portals: Candidates can update their info, schedule interviews, and check their status—less back-and-forth for you.
  • Branding & Career Page Tools: Clean, mobile-friendly landing pages so candidates remember you, not just the job post.
  • Analytics Dashboards: See what works (and what doesn’t) so you can adjust in real time.
  • Workflow Automation: Reminders, follow-ups, scheduling, note-taking—let the CRM do the boring parts.
  • AI Matching & Talent Rediscovery: Get recommendations for candidates you might’ve forgotten—yes, even that “almost perfect” runner-up from six months ago.

Picking the Right Candidate Relationship Management (Especially for Small and Medium-Sized Businesses)

Whether you’re in a big agency or a three-person HR team, the right CRM will fit your needs. If you’re a small or medium-sized business, you don’t need all the bells and whistles—just what helps you punch above your weight and keeps things simple.

👉 Curious how CRMs are changing the game for small and medium-sized businesses? I’ve got a post coming up just for SMBs—stay tuned for practical recommendations and tips. (I’ll link it here when it’s live!)

Here’s what to consider when shopping around:

  • Your hiring style: High-volume? Niche? Need to nurture passive talent? Pick features that match.
  • Ease of use: If it’s too complicated, no one will use it (trust me).
  • Growth-ready: Choose something that can grow as you do, so you’re not switching tools every year.
  • Integrations: Make sure it plays nice with your ATS, email, and calendar.
  • Analytics that make sense: You want actionable info, not data overload.
  • Security: GDPR/CCPA compliance isn’t optional.
  • Helpful support: Look for vendors who actually answer emails and offer real onboarding help.
  • No hidden fees: Read the fine print for setup, usage, and support costs.

A Few CRMs Recruiters Actually Like

Real Talk: AI and Automation for Small Teams

Don’t think CRMs are just for enterprise budgets. The best new CRMs use AI to handle reminders, match candidates, and even predict who’s most likely to succeed—giving small and medium-sized teams a real edge. You’ll save hours on follow-ups and have candidates actually remember you (instead of that “ghosted” feeling).

How to Start (Without Tech Overwhelm)

  1. Pick one pain point—maybe you always lose track of “silver medalist” candidates.
  2. Try a free trial—most CRMs offer them.
  3. Run a small pilot—test with your last 20 leads or one open role.
  4. See what saves you time, what’s confusing, and where you want help.
  5. Roll out to your whole team (with a little training).

Bottom Line

Recruiting shouldn’t be a guessing game or an endless hunt for old emails. The right CRM makes it easy to build real relationships and hire smarter—whether you’re a startup, a solo recruiter, or running a full HR department.
If you want help choosing a CRM, setting up workflows, or just a nudge in the right direction, I’m here for it—just reach out.

FAQ: Candidate Relationship Management Systems (CRM)

What is a Candidate Relationship Management (CRM) system, and how is it different from an ATS?

A CRM system helps recruiters organize, nurture, and engage with talent before a job is even open—think of it as your candidate “vault” and outreach engine. Unlike an Applicant Tracking System (ATS), which is designed to manage applicants for current roles, a CRM keeps tabs on passive candidates, lets you build talent pools, and maintains ongoing relationships, so you never lose touch with great people.

Why should recruiters and small HR teams care about using a CRM?

A good CRM saves you from losing promising candidates in your inbox, streamlines follow-ups, and helps you create a standout candidate experience—without big budgets or extra headcount. With features like automated outreach, talent rediscovery, and analytics, CRMs empower even small teams to act like talent pros and build hiring pipelines that are always warm.

What should I look for when choosing a CRM for recruiting?

Prioritize ease of use, seamless integration with your existing tools (ATS, email, calendar), and features that match your hiring style (like automation, AI matching, and candidate portals). Look for transparent pricing, solid customer support, and analytics that are actually useful—not just more data to wade through. And always check for security compliance, especially with GDPR/CCPA if you handle candidate data.

And if you’re running a small or medium-sized team, don’t miss my upcoming post breaking down the best CRMs and tricks for SMBs. I’ll add the link right here soon!

Scroll to Top
MakeTheHire.com
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.